6 approved scenarios currently published.
Additional developed cases remain private until they pass the same evidence controls.
NFR-0051
2018 Evidence-controlled
TSB Bank plc
The FCA and PRA found that TSB's data migrated successfully in April 2018, but the new platform failed immediately; disruption affected all branches and a significant proportion of 5.2 million customers, with £48.65 million in combined penalties.
Technology & Change Risk
Operational Resilience
Third-Party & Concentration Risk
Change & release management
Open NFR-0051
NFR-0052
2012 Approved reference case
Royal Bank of Scotland, NatWest and Ulster Bank
A 2012 software compatibility failure disrupted core banking processes, affected at least 6.5 million UK customers and resulted in £56 million of combined FCA and PRA penalties.
Technology & Change Risk
Operational Resilience
Data & Control Integrity
Payments Risk
Open NFR-0052
NFR-0085
2006 Evidence-controlled
Volkswagen AG
Volkswagen pleaded guilty in 2017 to three federal felonies after software distinguished emissions testing from normal driving; the US federal resolution totalled $4.3 billion and concerned approximately 590,000 diesel vehicles.
Conduct & Governance Risk
Data & Control Integrity
Physical, Safety & Environmental Risk
System & back-out testing
Open NFR-0085
NFR-0003
2004 Evidence-controlled
BNP Paribas S.A.
BNP Paribas pleaded guilty in 2014 to conspiring to violate US sanctions law after moving more than $8.8 billion through the US financial system for sanctioned entities; the plea agreement imposed $8.9736 billion in total financial penalties.
Financial Crime & Control Integrity
Data & Control Integrity
Conduct & Governance Risk
Sanctions
Open NFR-0003
NFR-0014
2001 Evidence-controlled
Siemens AG
Siemens AG and three subsidiaries pleaded guilty to FCPA-related offences in 2008; coordinated US and German resolutions exceeded $1.6 billion and included a four-year independent compliance monitor.
Financial Crime & Control Integrity
Conduct & Governance Risk
Data & Control Integrity
Bribery & corruption
Open NFR-0014
NFR-0044
1999 Evidence-controlled
Post Office Limited - Horizon
The Court of Appeal found a material risk that apparent branch shortfalls were caused by Horizon bugs, errors or defects and quashed 39 appellants' convictions in 2021; legislation in 2024 then quashed qualifying convictions more broadly.
Data & Control Integrity
Conduct & Governance Risk
Data integrity
Control assurance
Open NFR-0044